wech©¯Í ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ : W. Ave`yj jwZd gvmyg

ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZi cÖe³v cyiælØq: M¨vweÖ‡qj A¨vjgÛ Ges wmWwb fve©v Zv‡`i myweL¨vZ MÖš’ Ô`¨ wmwfK KvjPviÕ(1963) G ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZi we‡kølY Ges wefvRb K‡i‡Qb| jywmqvb WweøD cvB-Gi e¨vL¨vq ejv hvq: GKwU mgv‡Ri ivR‰bwZK AvPiY, g~j¨‡eva Ges ixwZ-bxwZi mgwóB IB mgv‡Ri ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ| `xN©Kvj a‡i Abym…Z evsjv‡`‡ki ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ ÔmsKxY©Õ G K_v ejv KwVb| AvR‡Ki evsjv‡`‡k Avgiv †h ms¯‹…wZi cwiPq cvw”Q Avm‡jB wK Zv Avgv‡`i ivRbxwZi g~javivi cÖwZwbwaZ¡ K‡i? Avgv‡`i AvPvi-AvPi‡Y Ges ivR‰bwZK Kvh©Kjv‡c †h ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ Dc¯’vwcZ n‡”Q Zv wK †gŠwjK, bv K…wÎg? mv¤úÖwZK M‡elYvq ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ‡K `yB fv‡M fvM Kiv n‡q‡Q: ev¯Íe Ges Av‡ivwcZ| RbMY Avm‡jB hv wek¦vm K‡i Ges aviY K‡i Zv n‡”Q Ôev¯Íe ms¯‹…wZÕ| Aciw`‡K Av‡ivwcZ ms¯‹…wZ n‡”Q Zv, hv kw³ A_ev fxwZ cÖ`k‡b©i gva¨‡g RbM‡Yi Ici Pvwc‡q †`qv nq| (A·‡dvW© wWKkbvwi Ae †mvwmIjwR: 2009: 572) GB ZË¡ K_vUyKy g‡b ivL‡j Avgv‡`i B`vbxs ivR‰bwZK AvPiY Ges D”PvwiZ kãvewj †evSv mnRZi n‡e|

Avgiv AvPi‡Y bv n‡jI msweavb †gvZv‡eK GKwU MYZvwš¿K mgv‡R emevm Kwi| msm`xq MYZš¿ gv‡bB n‡”Q eû`jxq ivR‰bwZK e¨e¯’v| GLv‡b ivR‰bwZK `j GKwU Acwinvh© Abym½| †h `j RbM‡Yi m¤§wZ jvf K‡i Zviv GKwU wbw`©ó †gqv‡`i Rb¨ kvmb Kivi AwaKvi jvf K‡i| RvZxq msm‡` hviv miKv‡ii c‡i †ewk Avmb cvq Zviv we‡ivax `‡ji gh©v`v jvf K‡i| we‡ivax †bÎx Avgv‡`i †`‡kI gš¿xi gh©v`v cvq| Avi msm‡` †hme `‡ji Avmb _v‡K Zv‡`i‡KI Dchy³ m¤§vb †`qv nq| m¤§vb †`qv nq GB Kvi‡Y †h we‡ivax gv‡b kÎy bq| GKB ivR‰bwZK e¨e¯’vq wfbœgZ †cvlYKvix gvÎ| Avgv‡`i ivR‰bwZK ˆewiZv kÎyZvq ch©ewmZ n‡Z †`‡L m‡PZb bvMwiK gvÎB wePwjZ|

weMZ K‡qK mßvn a‡i Avgv‡`i †`‡k Av‡›`vjb Pj‡Q| weGbwc †Pqvicvimb, 20 `jxq †bÎx Ges mv‡eK cÖavbgš¿x †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqv Ae‡iv‡ai WvK w`‡q‡Qb| Zvi Abym…Z ivRbxwZ Ges ivR‰bwZK †KŠkj ev Kg©m~wPi m‡½ mevB GKgZ n‡eb- GUv bvI n‡Z cv‡i| cÖwZwU bvMwi‡Ki AwaKvi i‡q‡Q Zvi Kg©m~wPi K‡Vvi mgv‡jvPbv Kivi| wbZ¨w`b P¨v‡b‡j Ges cÎ cwÎKvq Gme mgv‡jvPbvI j¶¨ Kiv hvq| we‡klZ ˆeix miKvwi `j Av‡›`vjb‡K wfbœfv‡e e¨vL¨v Ki‡e- GUvB ¯^vfvweK| wKš‘ hv A¯^vfvweK Zv n‡”Q Zvi cÖwZ AvPiY Ges Av‡ivwcZ kãvejx|

1. †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqv 3iv Rvbyqvwi 2015 hLb Zvi Kvh©vjq †_‡K m¤¢ve¨ mgv‡ek ¯’‡j iIbv †`b ZLb Zv‡K †M‡U AvU‡K †`qv nq| ïay ZvB bq ciw`b BU evjyi UÖvK w`‡q Zvi Kvh©vjq wN‡i †`qv nq| kÕ kÕ cywjk †gvZv‡qb Kiv nq, hv‡Z wZwb †ei bv n‡Z cv‡ib| Gfv‡e 20 w`b Zv‡K Aeiæ× ivLv nq| miKvi †_‡K ejv nq, Zvi wbivcËv evov‡bv n‡q‡Q| GKRb gš¿x e‡jb, BU-evjy Lv‡j`v wRqv G‡b‡Qb Zvi feb wbg©v‡Yi Rb¨|
2. GKRb L¨vwZgvb gš¿x cÖKv‡k¨ †NvlYv †`b, Lv‡j`v wRqvi we`y¨r, †Uwj‡dvb Ges cvwbi jvBb †K‡U †`qv n‡e| A‡b‡K GUv‡K ïay ûgwK g‡b Ki‡jI GKw`b mwZ¨ mwZ¨B †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqvi Kvh©vj‡qi we`y¨r, †Uwj‡dvb Ges B›Uvi‡b‡Ui jvBb †K‡U †`qv nq| jvBb †K‡U †`qv †jv‡Kiv e‡j _vbvi wb‡`©‡k Zviv G KvR K‡i‡Q| ¸jkvb _vbv e‡j Zviv wKQyB Rv‡b bv| gš¿x e‡jb, Kg©Pvix Ges we¶yä kÖwgKiv IB jvBb †K‡U w`‡q‡Q| Avi GKRb gš¿x IB jvBb †K‡U †`qvi Rb¨ kÖwgK Kg©Pvix‡`i ab¨ev` Rvbvb|

1. †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqvi Kg©m~wP Øviv GmGmwm cix¶v e¨vnZ n‡j wkï‡`i w`‡q Zvi Kvh©vj‡qi m¤§y‡L gvbeeÜb Kiv‡bv nq| eviK‡qK ¶gZvmxb `‡ji wewfbœ A½msMVb †NivI-Gi †NvlYv w`‡q IB Kvh©vj‡qi AwZ wbK‡U †cŠu‡Q hvq| GKRb hyeK Zvi Kvh©vj‡q BU wb‡¶c Ki‡j Zv‡K cvMj e‡j †Q‡o †`qv nq| SvUv wgwQjKvix‡`i‡K Zvi Kvh©vj‡qi m¤§y‡L Ae¯’vb Kivi AbygwZ †`qv nq| †bŠcwienb gš¿xi mivmwi †bZ…‡Z¡ kÖwgK Kg©Pvixiv we‡¶vf wgwQj wb‡q G¸‡j KK‡Uj wb‡¶‡ci NUbv N‡U| Gme wbivcËvnxbZvi gv‡S hLb Kvh©vj‡q KvUvZv‡ii †eov †`qv nq ZLb `vwqZ¡kxj †jv‡Kiv weiƒc gšÍe¨ K‡i|

1. mv‡eK ciivóª cÖwZgš¿x Ges †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqvi Dc‡`óv wiqvR ingvb IB Kvh©vj‡q Zvi m‡½ †`Lv Kivi ciciB ¸wjwe× nb| Av‡iK Dc‡`óv †gvmv‡ÏK Avjx, †eMg wRqvi m‡½ †`Lv Ki‡Z †M‡j cywjk Zv‡K †MÖßvi K‡i| GLb †KD Zvi m‡½ †`Lv Ki‡Z †M‡j †M‡U iw¶Z †iwR÷ªv‡i ¯^v¶i Ki‡Z e‡j cywjk|

1. GKch©v‡q †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqvi Kvh©vj‡qi Lvevi eÜ K‡i †`qv nq| P¨v‡b‡j cÖPvwiZ Qwe‡Z †`Lv hvq Lvevi enbKvix wiKkv f¨vbwU Kvh©vj‡qi †M‡U †cŠuQ‡j cywjk f¨vbMvwo PvjK‡K †fZ‡i XyK‡Z †`qwb| eis GKRb cywjk f¨vbMvwo‡Z D‡V e‡m Lvevi¸‡jv ¸jkvb _vbvq wb‡q hvq| Ab¨ GKwU msev` wP‡Î (`¨ †WBwj ÷vi, 16B †deªæqvwi, †kl c…ôv) †`Lv hvq Avn~Z Lvevi dyUcv‡Z †i‡L w`‡q mv`v †cvkv‡Ki GKRb cywjk wiKkvIqvjv‡K Zvwo‡q †`q| wRÁvwmZ n‡j mswkøó cywjk e‡j ÔDc‡ii wb‡`©kÕ| wewkó KÉwkíx †eex bvRbxb †Kvb GK mܨvq †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqvi Rb¨ ivbœv Kiv wKQy Lvevi wb‡q †M‡j Zv‡K AvUK Kiv nq| ¯^ivóª cÖwZgš¿x Lvevi bv wb‡Z †`qvi welqwU A¯^xKvi K‡ib| AvIqvgx jxM †bZv W. nvQvb gvngy` e‡jb, Lvevi wb‡q †eMg Lv‡j`v wRqv bvUK Ki‡Qb| Ae‡k‡l msm‡` cÖavbgš¿x e‡jb, ÔAwd‡m _vKvi wK hyw³ Zv Avgiv eywS bv| Dwb Awd‡m e‡m Av‡Qb| Avevi wKQy `iw` †`Ljvg wjL‡Q, Ibvi Lvevi hv‡”Q bv| Awd‡m Lvevi hv‡e †Kb? Awd‡m Avm‡e, Awdm Ki‡e, Awdm †k‡l evwo wdi‡e| evwo‡Z wM‡q Lvevi Lv‡e|Õ

Gme NUbvejx Ges e³e¨ ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZi †Kvb ch©v‡qi cÖwZwbwaZ¡ K‡i †m wel‡q gšÍe¨ Ki‡Z PvB bv| ïay GUyKy ejv hvq evsjv‡`‡ki gvbyl‡K †evKv fvevi †Kvb KviY †bB|

1. AvPiY ms¯‹…wZ †`L‡jb| D”PviY AviI ZxeÖ Ges wnsmÖ| ¶gZvmxb `‡ji gš¿x, Aa©gš¿x Ges †bZv, cvwZ †bZviv cÖwZw`b Lv‡j`v wRqv‡K KUy K_v e‡j hv‡”Qb| †mme fvlv wjL‡j wØZxqevi Ab¨vq n‡e †f‡e Avi D‡jøL Kijvg bv| Gme †`‡L †`‡k GKRb cÖexY e¨w³Z¡ ˆmq` Aveyj gKmy` gšÍe¨ K‡ib, ÔAmy›`i fvlvq KvD‡K MvjvMvj †`qv Avi Mv‡q nvZ †Zvjvi g‡a¨ cv_©K¨ †Kv_vq?Ó (cÖ_g Av‡jv, 17B †deªæqvwi, 2015)|

evsjv‡`‡ki mgvR ms¯‹…wZ Ges Rxeb‡eva m¤ú‡K© hv‡`i b¨~bZg aviYv Av‡Q Dch©y³ NUbvejx Zv‡`i‡K wbtm‡›`‡n wew¯§Z Ki‡e| GB †mB †`k, †h †`‡ki gvbyl wb‡R bv †L‡q ci‡K LvIqvq| GB †mB †`k, †h †`‡ki gvbyl Aci‡K m‡e©v”P gh©v`v †`q| GB †mB †`k, †h †`‡k MvjvMvwj nvbvnvwb gvivgvwi Ly‡bvLywb‡K gvbyl N…Yv K‡i| wnsmv cÖwZwnsmv †MÖßvwi ev nZ¨vi ûgwKi g‡Zv NUbvejx‡K mvaviY gvbyl ¯^vfvweK g‡b K‡i bv| G †`‡ki gvbyl g‡b K‡i gvbweK Av‡e`b w`‡qB Pjgvb gvbweK wech©q‡K AwZµg Ki‡Z n‡e| evsjv‡`‡ki Avengvb jvwjZ ms¯‹…wZi wecix‡Z cÖwZdwjZ eZ©gvb ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ GKwU AvcvZ, K…wÎg Ges Av‡ivwcZ NUbv n‡Z eva¨| ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ we‡klÁiv g‡b K‡ib, ÒWhen a political culture collapses or is thrown in doubt, a crisis of legetimacy is createdP. (c~‡e©v³) A_©vr ÔhLb GKwU ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZ †f‡O c‡o ev m‡›`n m¼‡U wbcwZZ nq ZLb ˆeaZvi m¼U m…wó nqÕ| Avi evsjv‡`‡ki m‡PZb gvbyl gvÎB Rv‡bb Avgiv GLb GKwU ˆeaZvi m¼U mgq AwZµg KiwQ| ˆeaZvi m¼U m…wó nq ZLb, hLb ivR‰bwZK KZ©…Z¡ mZ¨‡K wg_¨v e‡j cÖPvi K‡i, e¨_©Zv‡K PgK, cÖZviYv Ges lohš¿ w`‡q †X‡K w`‡Z Pvq| G ai‡bi ivR‰bwZK `y‡h©vM mnmvB bvMwiK mvaviY‡K †MvUv e¨e¯’vi cÖwZ w¶ß K‡i Zyj‡Z cv‡i| myZivs ivRbxwZK Ges Avgjv‡`i DwPZ Avengvb jvwjZ evsjvi mnRvZ ivR‰bwZK ms¯‹…wZi jvjb-cvjb, aviY-msi¶Y Ges cÖwZ¯’vcb- wbwðZ Kiv| gvbeRwgb